It may be a good idea to quote discussion that happened so far here:
Quote:ColoBOT:
[colobot/colobot-misc master] 89ba104 https://git.io/vaQxK RaptorParkowsky: Fixed TerranovaTeam & ICC logos proportions and added title variants
22 Mar 19:36
Simbax:
"fixed"? What is "fixed"? Nobody complained about the logos and you dare change them without consulting with anyone and then commit the changes with a message "Fixed". I feel offended.
22 Mar 19:45
Simbax:
Nevermind, sorted it out on priv.
22 Mar 19:47
krzys_h:
I don't agree with this being the 'fixed' version, the previous ones were better
22 Mar 21:25
krzys_h:
Besides, why change something that is good and we all got used to already?
22 Mar 21:27
krzys_h:
This logo is already recognized by people, you cannot just change it for no good reason
22 Mar 21:28
tomaszkax86:
What was changed anyway? And why?
22 Mar 22:04
krzys_h:
tomaszkax86: http://imgur.com/a/J7omu
22 Mar 22:21
krzys_h:
why? that's exactly what I'm asking
22 Mar 22:21
erihel:
well calling it fixed is a bit strange
22 Mar 22:24
tomaszkax86:
To be honest, new versions look subjectively better, but did we actually discuss the need for change?
22 Mar 22:25
erihel:
but if you didn't start to argue here i wouldn't notice it ;p
22 Mar 22:25
krzys_h:
you can barely see this, but the colors have changed too
22 Mar 22:25
krzys_h:
tomaszkax86: I personally prefer the old ones, but it may be just that I'm so used to them already
22 Mar 22:26
krzys_h:
and we did NOT discuss that they need a change, Raptor suddenly decided to change them without telling anyone for no reason
22 Mar 22:27
erihel:
green is different but the blue one?
22 Mar 22:27
krzys_h:
BTW, changing a logo is not as simple as pushing to the repository, they are used in a lot of places, updating them is going to be a huge hassle
22 Mar 22:28
krzys_h:
erihel: blue changed background #23C3FF to #00C0FF and the letters from #00547D to #005080
22 Mar 22:29
tomangelo:
Looks like Raptor did something he usually tried to avoid - make some fragmentation
22 Mar 23:43
tomangelo:
Now there will be different versions of our logo around Internet
22 Mar 23:43
Quote:» RaptorParkowsky:
Sorry about the logos, but I just can't struggle those proportions and I thought that change would be good step forward, especially in time when we are not fully established community yet. Of course naming that "fixed" was a bad mistake, because the old ones wasn't bad designed logos or something, and I'm totally sorry for that bad chosen word in the name of the commit. The old ones was only non-perfect as it could be imo, so I decided to tweak them to be 100% compatible with official "COLOBOT" logo font and not to be so big change comparing to the old ones. I'll take the responsibility for replacing this logo in most of the places so don't worry about fragmentation. And I'm really sorry for not consulting this change with the others, but in these days I'm really determined for making any content because I have now not so much time for this and there's a lot of not finished graphic content on my HDD waiting for my free time. This isn't completely redesigned logo though. This is only an evolution of the old, good design.
23 Mar 07:37
» krzys_h:
@RaptorParkowsky but you realize that this logo is already in so many places you won't ve able to change them all?
23 Mar 07:59
» krzys_h:
And still, I petsonally prefer the old ones. I will not approve of changing them unless you make a poll and get most of the community to vote for YES.
23 Mar 08:01
» krzys_h:
There is no reason to change the logos everybody agreed on long ago now
23 Mar 08:02
» Simbax:
You know, the old design was kind of boring, so I think it's time for a complete redesign. I've worked all night on the TerranovaTeam logo and I'm pretty satisfied with the result, although I'm not sure if we can use the font for free. I may do the ICC version soon. Let me know what you think: http://i.imgur.com/qkuOt2J.png
23 Mar 08:33
» krzys_h:
@Simbax Awesome! We should start using the new one right away.
23 Mar 08:51
» RaptorParkowsky:
https://trello.com/b/6FROdZb5/icc-general - The poll for TerranovaTeam members.
23 Mar 22:42
» RaptorParkowsky:
@krzys_h : Of course I'm completely aware that "Internet never forget". But nobody complains about that we can still dig up old CocaCola or Microsoft (aka MicroSoft) logos. They're still recognizable despite differences, just like our old vs new logos.
23 Mar 22:46
» RaptorParkowsky:
@Simbax : "http://i.imgur.com/qkuOt2J.png" Nope. My photoshoping is better than yours ;P http://i.imgur.com/TQpsyyp.png (especially that green shadow...)
23 Mar 22:52
» tomaszkax86:
Why exactly is this poll on Trello? And is it actually a poll or just two cards you can "vote" for? Seriously, what are you doing?
24 Mar 01:33
» krzys_h:
Why is it even on Trello? We already discussed that Trello is NOT a place for such a poll because not all TerranovaTeam members look there often enough. Make it on the forum.
24 Mar 11:07
» krzys_h:
And I think there should be at least three options: "New look better, change", "New look better, but there is no reason to change them right now" and "Old are better"
24 Mar 11:09
» RaptorParkowsky:
Ok. Done. I thought we should use somehow this Trello until this will extinct...
24 Mar 12:01